Zee News
India Edition |International Edition
November 21, 2009
         
BJP accepts defeat; blames EVMs
Updated on Thursday, October 22, 2009, 15:14 IST Tags:Maharashtra Haryana ArunachalAssembly election results
Zeenews Bureau

New Delhi: As initial trends showed that the Congress is leading in all three states undergoing counting of votes on Thursday, BJP levelled a serious allegation of poll fraud against the Grand Old Party of India.

“EVMs have become ‘electronic victory machines’ for the Congress,” BJP vice president Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi told reporters from the party headquarter here. He is also the BJP election in-charge for assembly polls in Maharashtra, Haryana and Arunachal Pradesh.

He said he had got reports from many constituencies in Maharashtra and Haryana of hundreds of votes being polled with an hour. “That is impossible as it would mean many votes were cast in a single minute on one machine,” he added.

Naqvi said these elections were conducted with EVMs despite many parties expressing concern over their functioning.

Reacting to the charge, Congress said BJP was a bad loser and had nothing else to say in the face of defeat.

When asked if EVMs were manipulated in the past in states like Chhattisgarh and Gujarat where the BJP had won, Naqvi said, "Don't look at the results but at the credibility of EVMs."

However, soon after he retracted on his statement, ostensibly after being pressurized by the party higher-ups.

"I would request you not to look at these assembly elections from the point of view of EVMs alone. Once all the results are announced, we will analyse the reasons for the party's performance," Naqvi said.

When asked if he was backtracking on the issue under pressure, Naqvi said, "We will take up the issue of EVMs with the Election Commission. The technical question is still there."

Meanwhile in Maharashtra, Shiv Sena-BJP combine on Thursday conceded defeat in the Assembly elections with state party chief Gopinath Munde accepting the result.

"If it is a defeat, it has to be accepted by everybody," Shiv Sena leader and former Lok Sabha Speaker Manohar Joshi said when asked if the party conceded defeat in the elections.

"We are thinking as to how these results have come.. We never expected these results," he added.

Initial trends showed that the ruling Congress-NCP combine leading in 119 seats, while Shiv Sena-BJP combine ahead in 92 seats.

Asked about the reasons behind the performance of the combine in the state, BJP state president Nitin Gadkari said, "If there is a defeat, it is a defeat of everybody. If it is a victory, it is everybody's victory. I don't want to blame anybody for the defeat."


Toolbox
aPrint this pages
Post Your Comment     |    aAlert Moderator
Your comment(s) on this article
The proverb that ``a bad workman quarells with is tools`` holds good in the case of BJP which instead of accepting defeat gracefully in the recent assembly polls in Maharashtra, Haryana and Arunachal Pradesh are blaming the EVMs. Does it mean that the same EVMs would have been ideal, had the BJP won the assembly elections.? The BJP vice president Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi`s remarks blaming the EVMs are perhaps a pointer to his own defeat in the Lok Sabha elections. It is time, BJP sets its own house in order to maintain its position as a national party, now in opposition in the parliament. -PP TALWAR - India a
Can v say that victory in gujarat for BJP for last 3 state assembly election is due to EVM or the development work done by cheif minister?. Don`t make EVM scapegoat. If v argue that Mah. win is due to EVM?? -svm - valsad a
It is all matter of programing, in last Lok Sabha elections there were reports that the oposition got nill votes in many booths which raises doubts and is a clear indication that the EVM`s were tempered, please check some machiens used in last Lok Sabha Elections were the doubd is very gross, we are sure the real fact will come out, please note that in the by elections in most states where congress govt. was not ruling the BJP got victory and congress was defeated wether it was Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, Himachal, Uttarakhand or MCD Polls of Delhi in all areas congress was defeated. We have talked to many people in our contact they said they had voted for the BJP in in Lok Sabha elections but we are surprised that not only the BJP was defeated but the margin of defeat was doubt raising in many areas. Please think sereously it is a matter for removing the most corrupt party of Post Indipandent India. Jai Hind -N.D.A. - Delhi a
BJP is dead...and India has no alternative other than Congress.. We can see the result.. As far as Mr. Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi is concerned...he himself doesn`t knows wht reason he sud give.. -Pooja - Mumbai a
Ravi kanna, do you want to say by using EVM, BJP will be in power in Karnataka forever. And BJP rigged & won recent bi-election in Karnataka. BE HONEST Ravi!! -abu muhammad - mangalore a
Poor Naqvi, pity on you. You better boycott all future elections in India where EVM is used. Any how your party want to take back India to MANU YUG. Wait until then. Truth is very hard to digest!! -hasan abbas - Riyadh a
Points of doubt 0)Sonia and raghul and family ,are not honest 1)Moreover Congress not having proper policy on anything. 2)So, these kind of winning rising questions on EVM . 3)It risisng questions on honesty of CEC (Naveen chawla). 4)Still election commission not proved that malfunctions connot be done on EVM. 5)Election commission dragging all the cases regarding EVM without proper answer. 5)According to the doubts above the party who is in power, they will be in power always. -Ravi Kannan A - Bangalore a
i agree with bjp`s statement -vimal mehta - rohtak - haryana a
Mr.Navin chawla the chief election commissioner will be the followinga)Ambassodor b) governor c)Minister with Rajyasbah membership.You wii see this with in six months after his retirement in 2010 a.l.a.a M.S Gill.Mr Gopalaswami will be proved right and the stupid Nram will get a slap on his face though not literally -sankar - Bangalore a
It is bad work of BJP Govt`s and Hankar bhara attitude of BJP leader which is deafeating them through EVM and being a BJP worker I will we will never win Elections again in Inia if it continioued. -RAJESH - HARYANA a